Text
June 21, 2012

prettylittlelyingbitches asked: I really like your Melissa is the black swan theory! I see it better now. When the girls left for the ball Spencer said "Melissa's curled up on the couch in her pajamas", but when we see Melissa "next" she's at the scene of Maya's death. She would have time to be the black swan and then get home and change into regular clothes because the black swan ran out early.

yes ! it might be answered in the next episode as it shows the feathers i think it is in the much music promo. it has to be her. yes she had plenty of time to do all of that ! and the fact that she has been the black swan before? same costume maybe? the whole aria/black swan movie promo coincidence? i think it was thrown in by the writers to throw us off. she HAS TO BE the black swan haha. 

Tags: pll pretty little liars abc family abc melissa hastings black swan a masquerade ball unmAsked season 2 season 3 spencer hastings aria montgomery emily fields hanna marin costume television muchmusic promo

Photo
June 21, 2012
5 notes
the black swan IS melissa hastings (torrey devitto).come on every body look at their necks, exactly the same.compare ashley marins neck now to the black swan, nothing alike.  Does everyone agree that Melissa is definitely the black swan?  

the black swan IS melissa hastings (torrey devitto).

come on every body look at their necks, exactly the same.

compare ashley marins neck now to the black swan, nothing alike. 

Does everyone agree that Melissa is definitely the black swan?

 

Tags: pll pretty little liars abc family television black swan melissa hastings

Photoset
March 30, 2012
2 notes

One of the biggest questions of Pretty Little Liars’ Season 2 Finale ‘unmAsked’ was:
who is the Black Swan?
Looking at different people’s opinions, I would say that the three biggest contenders of who is the Black Swan would be Melissa Hastings, Ashely Marin and Aria Montgomery. 


Out of these three contenders, I personally believe that the more likely option is Melissa Hastings. The only doubt about this theory I have is because she is supposed to be pregnant. Somehow and for reasons unknown, I honestly believe she is faking the pregnancy. The black swan’s facial structure, hair colour and body type looks too much like that of Melissa Hastings. Plus we have the proof from Spencer that she has been the Black Swan before at a charity event in Philadelphia. We have no proof to say she didn’t attend the ball. The sketches found in A’s motel room was also that of Melissa’s dress.

Then we move onto that of Ashely Marin, who has a similar hair colour, body type and facial structure. Her first name does begin with an A. What reason does Ashely have to want to hurt her daughter and her friends or dress up to come to a ball and communicate with Jenna and Lucas? I might be narrow-minded but I just can’t see it.

Next contender is one of the pretty little liars herself which is Aria Montgomery who also has a first name beginning with the letter A. Marlene King who is the writer of the series tweeted that red is the new black. After looking at promotional images of the movie ‘Black Swan’, we find that the design is similar to that of Aria’s dress.  This gets me thinking but because Aria is one of my favourite characters, I just really don’t want to see it. Red Herring?

share with me your thoughts?

Tags: melissa hastings unmAsked black swan lucas ian jenna marshell toby cavannaugh ashley benson shay mitchell lucy hale Aria Montgomery abc family television mystery Alison DiLaurentis Spencer Hastings Hanna Marin Emily Fields